| 2004 Derek Jeter & Gary Sheffield Game Used Bat Card |
| 2004 GARY SHEFFIELD SP AUTHENTIC ALL-STAR MOMENTS #199! |
| 2004 SWEET SPOT GARY SHEFFIELD TRUE 1/1 PRINTING PLATE |
| 2004 UPPER DECK POWER UP ORANGE GARY SHEFFIELD 100 PTS |
| 2004 LEAF CERTIFIED GARY SHEFFIELD BAT CARD 228/250! |
| 2004 Gary Sheffield Yankees GU Dual Patch Upper Deck |
| 2004 Bowman Heritage Threads of Greatness Sheffield |
| 2004 Topps Heritage Chrome Gary Sheffield #1396/ 1955 |
| 2004 PLAYOFF HONORS GARY SHEFFIELD GU BAT /250 |
| 2004 Donruss Elite Aspirations Gary Sheffield #35/89 |
| 2004 Elite Extra Draft Class R Clemens/G Sheffield /500 |
| 2004 Ultra Season Crown Game Used 56 G. Sheffield Bat |
| 2004 Playoff Gary Sheffield Game Used Jersey /250 |
| 2004 Donruss Production Line OPS #3 Gary Sheffield/1023 |
| 2004 Topps Hit Parade #HP10 Gary Sheffield NY Yankees |
| 9 card 2004 Topps Chrome Gold Refractor lot Sheffield |
| 2004 Upper Deck Super Sluggers #11 GARY SHEFFIELD |
| 2004 Topps Hit Parade #HP20 Gary Sheffield NY Yankees |
| 2004 TOPPS ALL-STAR #TAS9 GARY SHEFFIELD |
| 2004 TOPPS CLUBHOUSE- J.VAZQUEZ/F.MCGRIFF/G.SHEFFIELD |
| 2004 Derek Jeter & Gary Sheffield Game Used Bat Card |